Strategy
Score for the Scene: What Justice's GTA 6 Score Teaches About Writing for Sync
Rockstar hired Justice for their sound, then asked them to score a game where the music changes with whatever the player is doing. The French duo of Gaspard Augé and Xavier de Rosnay wrote the score for Grand Theft Auto VI, which came out on 19 November, and the score album follows on 11 December. Their own rule for it: every track is tailored to a scene, and every track has to work on its own.
That's the lesson for an independent artist, and it isn't really about games. The people who pay for music in film, TV, ads and games start from a picture and a feeling. If you can hear your own tracks that way, and write new ones that way, you can answer a brief. If you only describe them by genre and tempo, you're describing them in a language buyers don't search in.
What Justice were actually asked for
The score album is out on 11 December through Because Music, Ed Banger and Rockstar Games: 30 tracks plus digital bonus tracks, about three hours of music in all. Rockstar calls it an adaptive score, and Because Music's announcement says it's "dynamically tuned to game events as they unfold". In plain terms, the music reacts to what the player does, the way a film score follows the cut, except here the player is doing the cutting.
De Rosnay explained why the range had to be so wide:
Notice the order: emotions come first, genres second. The duo also set themselves a rule, which Eurogamer reported in English: "The music always had to be listenable on its own, even if each track is tailored for [a specific] scene."
There's a small contradiction in that, and I like it. Rockstar's own announcement says Justice bring "their signature sound" to the game. So the sound is what got them the call. Covering every feeling a game that size needs was the job.
Why the people who buy music think in scenes
A music supervisor or a video editor almost always has the picture before the music. There's a cut, a 30-second ad, a level in a game. What's missing is a feeling the picture can't carry on its own, like the tension before a door opens or the flat quiet after bad news.
You can see it in how production libraries organise their catalogues, because they're built around how buyers search. Epidemic Sound's mood browser lists Sad and Hopeful, and right next to them it lists Chasing, Sneaking and Running. Those last three aren't emotions at all. They're things a camera sees. A buyer looking for a chase cue types "chasing", not "French house at 120 BPM".
None of this means genre doesn't matter. It means genre is a filter applied after the feeling, not the first thing anyone asks for. If you're new to sync, our sync licensing guide covers how placements work and what makes a track easy to license.
How to practise writing for a feeling
You don't need a Rockstar brief to train this. Here's how I'd go about it with a catalogue of your own.
- Re-tag what you've already made. For every track, write down one feeling and one scene it could sit under. "The drive home after you've lost" tells a supervisor more than "synthwave, 104 BPM, A minor". Keep the genre and tempo in your metadata, but lead with the feeling when you pitch.
- Write to briefs nobody sent you. Two lines is enough: what's on screen, and what the viewer should feel at the start and at the end. Give yourself 60 to 90 seconds. Most of the craft is in the change between the start and the end, which is exactly what an adaptive score like Justice's does at a much bigger scale.
- Bounce the versions an editor will ask for. An instrumental, a version without drums, and stems. An adaptive score is layers that come in and out as the game changes. An editor wants the same thing in a smaller form, so they can cut your track to their picture without calling you.
- Check it still works with the screen off. That's Justice's rule, and it's a money rule as much as an artistic one. A cue that only makes sense under picture earns its fee and then stops. A track that works as a song keeps earning on streaming.
If your whole draw is one recognisable sound and you don't want to write to someone else's picture, that's a fine way to have a career, and sync isn't compulsory. It's also a harder sell if you don't control your own masters and publishing: a supervisor on a deadline wants one person who can say yes to both, and an artist who has to ask a label first often loses the slot.
Three ways music in a game gets paid
The Justice project touches all three of the usual routes, which makes it a handy example. What it doesn't do is tell us their terms. Rockstar hasn't published them, and anyone quoting a figure for Justice's fee is guessing.
| Route | How it's paid | Does it keep paying? |
|---|---|---|
| A commissioned score | A fee to compose, with the terms set by contract. Game and film scores are often written as work for hire, where the studio owns the recordings. | Only through whatever the contract leaves the composer, such as a share of a soundtrack album |
| A licensed track | A sync fee for using an existing recording and song, usually agreed once, covering both the master and the composition | Not from the game itself, but a placement can send listeners to the original |
| A soundtrack album | Streaming and sales royalties, split between whoever owns the master and whoever owns the publishing | Yes, for as long as people listen |
Justice are in all three rows. They wrote the score. They're on the separate GTA VI: The Album with "Flower in a Hurricane", which features Tame Impala, SZA and King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard and is on the score album too. And from 11 December the score album earns streaming royalties like any other record. The detail I'd notice as an artist is the release: it's out through Because Music and Ed Banger, Justice's record labels, alongside Rockstar Games, not through Rockstar alone. How the money from it is split between them isn't public.
If you're pricing a placement of your own, our sync pricing and negotiation guide has fee ranges by type of placement, games included.
What the score album's streams could pay, modelled
The album is the part that keeps paying, so it's the part we can put through the calculator. These are modelled figures at the site's average Spotify rate of $0.004 a stream, not a forecast of how the album will do and not what Justice will earn.
| Total Spotify streams across the album | Modelled payout to rights holders |
|---|---|
| 1 million | $4,000 |
| 10 million | $40,000 |
| 100 million | $400,000 |
That's the gross a platform pays out for the recordings, before the labels, any distributor and the artists' own deal take their shares. Songwriting royalties are paid separately. The real rate moves with the listener's country and whether they pay for Spotify, and a three-hour album spreads its plays across more than 30 tracks, each of which needs 1,000 streams a year before Spotify pays on it at all.
The same arithmetic works at any size. Run your own catalogue through the Spotify royalty calculator and you'll see why a sync fee and a streaming tail are different kinds of money. One is a single payment. The other only exists if the track holds up as music when nobody's watching anything.
Start with three tracks
Pick three tracks from your catalogue. For each one, write a feeling and a scene, then delete the genre from the first line of your pitch. Then write yourself one fake brief, two lines long, and answer it in 90 seconds of music. Do that once a month. When a real brief turns up, you'll have tracks already described the way it's written and a few cues you made to order.
Home